Fresh-Baked Cookies
Baked from scratch in our on-site Cookie Kitchen — chocolate chip, peanut butter, M&M, snickerdoodle and always something new in the works.
Downtown Windsor · Open 7 Days a Week
The Sweetest Place in NoCo
A locally owned sweet shoppe on Main Street — cookies baked fresh in our Cookie Kitchen, hundreds of candies from the classic to the obscure, more than 60 bottled sodas, popsicles, gifts and toys. Life's short. Make it sweet.
503 Main St, Windsor, CO — just look for the pink door
7 daysopen every week
60+bottled sodas
100sof candies
1pink door — can't miss it
What We Sell
Something for everyone
Everything you'd expect from an old-time sweet shoppe — and a few things you wouldn't. Candy, cookies, soda-pop, toys, gifts, Colorado honey and much more.
The Candy Wall
Hundreds of different candies — classic, nostalgic, brand-new and even international finds you won't see anywhere else in town.
Soda-Pop & Popsicles
Over 60 kinds of bottled soda and a freezer full of novelty popsicles — plus seasonal treats that change with the calendar.
Toys, Gifts & Cards
A huge selection for kids and the young at heart — toys, games, greeting cards and gifts. Don't miss Colson's Corner!
Colorado Honey
Locally made Colorado honey in a rainbow of flavors — a taste of NoCo to take home or gift.
What The Fudge
Missy Kay's is the exclusive retail home of What The Fudge — fresh, delicious local fudge made in Eaton, Colorado.
Our Story
A family shoppe, named with love
Missy Kay's is the dream of husband-and-wife team Cody & Allison Neidert — Northern Colorado natives who met at the University of Northern Colorado, moved to Windsor in 2019, and opened the shoppe as a true family passion. Cody loves running candy and gift shops; Allison is an outstanding cookie baker and decorator.
The name comes from their daughter Margaret — "Missy Kay" is Daddy's nickname for Maggie Kay (her brother Colson has his own corner of the shop). And our Cookie Balloon logo? It celebrates Windsor's hot-air-balloon mornings and the beloved Harvest Festival balloon rally.
We're a Windsor family with a passion for puttin' smiles on faces. We hope to see you soon.
Visit the Shoppe
Find the pink door
In the heart of downtown Windsor, at the corner of Main St and 5th St, next to Four & Twenty Blackbirds Gift Shop — come visit us and the other wonderful shops and restaurants that make downtown special.
Hours
- Monday – Thursday10am – 6pm
- Friday – Saturday10am – 9pm
- Sunday11am – 5pm
Hours subject to change depending on business and the weather.
Good to Know
Sweet answers
Are the cookies really baked fresh in the shop?
Yes — cookies are baked on-site in our Cookie Kitchen: chocolate chip, peanut butter, M&M, snickerdoodle and more. We're always trying out something new and fun.
Can I order cookies in bulk for a gathering?
Absolutely. Choose your amount, flavors and pickup time and get a bulk discount. Call (970) 460-0307 to order.
Where exactly is the shoppe?
503 Main St in downtown Windsor, at the corner of Main and 5th, next to Four & Twenty Blackbirds Gift Shop. Just look for the pink door!
What is What The Fudge?
Fresh, delicious fudge made locally in Eaton, Colorado — and Missy Kay's is its exclusive retail home.
Who is Missy Kay?
It's the nickname of the owners' daughter, Margaret (Maggie) Kay — and her brother Colson has his own corner of the shop, full of fun finds.